More lists appear on the interwebs every day (expected soon: The [London] Guardian, KQED), and we'll add 'em as we see 'em.
- All About Jazz (Dan McClenaghan | John Kelman)
- AllMusic.com (Matt Collar; scroll down)
- The BBC's Jazz on 3 (Jez Nelson)
- Bird Is the Worm (Dave Sumner)
- Boston Globe (John Garelick)
- Burning Ambulance (Phil Freeman)
- Chicago Reader (Peter Margasak)
- Chicago Tribune (Howard Reich)
- Dark Forces Swing (Hank Shteamer)
- Ted Gioia
- The Jazz Breakfast (Peter Bacon)
- Jazz Chronicles (James Hale)
- Jazz Journalists Association (multiple lists)
- Nextbop/Art of Cool
- New York Times (Nate Chinen | Ben Ratliff)
- NPR (Francis Davis)
- NPR Jazz Critics Poll (survey of 140 jazz writers)
- Ottawa Citizen (Peter Hum)
- PopMatters (Will Layman & John Garratt)
- San Jose Mercury-News (Richard Scheinin)
- Gene Seymour (The Nation, etc.)
- Slate (Fred Kaplan)
- Something Else! (S. Victor Aaron)
- The (London) Telegraph
- Village Voice (David R. Adler)
- Wondering Sound / eMusic